on Jun 14, 2025

$500,000 Sold Price

$499,900Asking Price

53 Rustic Bay Street, Kawartha Lakes, ON K9V 4R6

Rural Fenelon, Kawartha Lakes

Detached
4
Bedrooms
1
Bath
6
Parking
Days on Market

Welcome to Your Lakeside Escape on Sturgeon Lake. Nestled on the serene shores of Sturgeon Lake, this charming 4-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and lake side tranquility. Whether you're searching for a weekend getaway, a family-friendly summer retreat, or a peaceful place to unwind, this property delivers the kind of lakefront lifestyle that's hard to find and even harder to leave behind. From the moment you step onto the property, the timeless character of this lake side gem is evident. Surrounded by mature trees and native greenery, the cottage is privately tucked away yet still fully accessible. One of the standout features of this cottage is the screened-in porch. Overlooking the water and just a short stroll from the dock, this space will quickly become your favorite part of the home. Start your mornings here with a mug of coffee as the sun rises over the water, afternoons fishing off the dock, and spend your evenings safe from the bugs while still feeling fully immersed in nature. There's also the potential to further enhance the property over time. Add a bunkie for guests, install a fire pit, or even renovate the cottage to winterize it for year-round use. With this much potential and a location like this, the options are wide open.

Welcome to Your Lakeside Escape on Sturgeon Lake. Nestled on the serene shores of Sturgeon Lake, this charming 4-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and lake side tranquility. Whether you're searching for a weekend getaway, a family-friendly summer retreat, or a peaceful place to unwind, this property delivers the kind of lakefront lifestyle that's hard to find and even harder to leave behind. From the moment you step onto the property, the timeless character of this lake side gem is evident. Surrounded by mature trees and native greenery, the cottage is privately tucked away yet still fully accessible. One of the standout features of this cottage is the screened-in porch. Overlooking the water and just a short stroll from the dock, this space will quickly become your favorite part of the home. Start your mornings here with a mug of coffee as the sun rises over the water, afternoons fishing off the dock, and spend your evenings safe from the bugs while still feeling fully immersed in nature. There's also the potential to further enhance the property over time. Add a bunkie for guests, install a fire pit, or even renovate the cottage to winterize it for year-round use. With this much potential and a location like this, the options are wide open.

Key Info

  • 1.5-Storey Detached
  • 6-Car Driveway
  • No Garage
  • Arbour St/Rustic Bay St.
  • 700-1100 Approximate Sq Feet
  • 51-99 Years Approximate Age
  • No Basement
  • 1 Kitchen
  • Electric Heating
  • No A/C

Property

  • Lot Size 53.92 x 113.2 Feet
  • < .50 Acreage
  • Vinyl Siding Exterior
  • Direct Waterfront Access
  • Taxes were $3,467 in 2024
  • Possession: TBA

Details

  • Fireplace
  • Family Room
  • Septic Tank
  • Well Water
  • Dug Well Water Supply
  •  
  • MLS #X12210195
  • BALL REAL ESTATE INC.

Extras

Room Floor Dimensions Details
1 Kitchen Main 12.50' x 8.92'
2 Bathroom Main 7.05' x 5.31' 4-PieceBath
3 Other Main 13.68' x 11.91'
Washroom1 4-Piece Bathroom on Main Floor

Who lives here?

Rural Fenelon, Kawartha Lakes is an east GTA neighbourhood notable for its university grads and education, law & public sector professionals. Residents tend to be older with a significant number of adults aged 60 to 64 and seniors aged 65 to 79.

Created with Highcharts 7.1.2Highcharts.com
BabiesKidsYouthAdultsAdultsSeniors

Families

Kids Per Family

0.7

kids per family
in the neighbourhood.

Kawartha Lakes  (0.8)

Singles

Created with Highcharts 7.1.2Highcharts.com

33% of residents are
single and loving it.

33% singles

Kawartha Lakes (38%)

Renters

Created with Highcharts 7.1.2Highcharts.com

7% of residents
are renters.

7% renters

Kawartha Lakes (17%)

Education

Created with Highcharts 7.1.2Highcharts.com

16% of residents are
university grads.

16% university grads

Kawartha Lakes (14%)

Income

Average Household Income

$95K

is the average household
income in the neighbourhood.

Kawartha Lakes  ($98K)

Professions

Professions

Trades 12%
Sales 10%
Government 8%
Business 7%
Management 5%

Immigrants

Created with Highcharts 7.1.2Highcharts.com

6% of residents were
born outside of Canada.

6% immigrants

Kawartha Lakes (7%)

Birthplace - All

UK was once home to 2.6% of immigrants.
USA 0.7%
Netherlands 0.6%
Italy 0.3%
Nigeria 0.3%

2.6% from UK
All-time

Foreign Languages

Foreign Languages

German 2%
French 1%

Religions

Religions

Christian 72%